Evidence & Methodology
Good investigation isn't about proving a preferred theory. It's about examining competing explanations, tracing evidence to its origins, and remaining willing to change a conclusion when new information emerges.
Provenance
Every source should be traceable to where it came from: the publisher, the location it was retrieved from and the date it was retrieved. A finding is only as strong as the records it can point back to.
Independence
Ten articles repeating one press release are one source, not ten. Maize tries to tell original reporting apart from repetition, and counts independent lines of evidence rather than mentions.
Original versus repeated reporting
Primary records such as filings, official reports, datasets and court documents are preferred over secondary accounts. Secondary material is useful for context and leads, and is labelled as such.
Corrections and version history
Case records are append-only versions. A correction adds a new version and leaves the earlier one visible, so changes in a conclusion can be traced and explained.
Limits of evidence
Records can be incomplete, redacted, mistaken or missing. Absence of a record is not proof that something did not happen, and presence of a name in a record is not proof of wrongdoing.
What "undetermined" means
Undetermined means the available evidence does not support choosing between the competing explanations. It is a finding in its own right, not a failure to answer.
Confidence is not correctness
A confident answer can still be wrong, and an AI system can sound certain without good grounds. Maize states what the evidence supports and how firmly, instead of relying on tone.
Challenging a finding
A finding can be challenged with a better source, a contradiction or a flaw in the reasoning. Any of these is a reason to reopen the question.
AI assistance
Maize is an AI system. Its output can contain errors and is not legal, medical, financial or professional investigative advice. Cluestery is not a licensed private investigation service.

